Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) for Trauma: A Comprehensive Review of Protocol and Efficacy
Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) is a highly specialized, eight-phase, empirically-supported psychotherapy developed by Francine Shapiro in the late 1980s. It is internationally recognized for its effectiveness in treating Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and other conditions resulting from adverse life experiences. The core therapeutic mechanism involves utilizing Bilateral Stimulation (BLS)—typically rapid, rhythmic eye movements—to stimulate the brain’s information processing system. This process is hypothesized to move disturbing memories from their emotionally isolated, dysfunctionally stored state to an integrated, adaptive resolution, essentially allowing the client to fully process the past event.
This comprehensive article will explore the historical genesis of EMDR, detail the theoretical framework—the Adaptive Information Processing (AIP) model—that underpins its efficacy, and systematically analyze the structured eight-phase protocol. Understanding the rigorous methodology and neurobiological rationale of EMDR is crucial for appreciating its transformative role in modern trauma-focused care, setting it apart from traditional cognitive and exposure therapies.
Time to feel better. Find a mental, physical health expert that works for you.
- Historical Development and Theoretical Foundations
The development of EMDR was rooted in an accidental discovery and subsequently formalized into a structured, replicable model, driven by the critical need for effective, rapid trauma treatment protocols.
- Genesis of the Model and Early Research
In 1987, psychologist Francine Shapiro observed that her own distressing thoughts seemed to diminish in intensity when her eyes spontaneously moved rapidly from side to side while walking. This serendipitous observation led to her systematically studying the effect of deliberate eye movements on anxiety and distress related to traumatic memories in her clinical practice.
- Initial Protocol and Name: Shapiro initially coined the term “Eye Movement Desensitization” (EMD), focusing primarily on the desensitization component—the reduction of emotional charge attached to the memory.
- Refinement and Expansion: As the protocol expanded to include cognitive reprocessing (linking the memory to a positive belief) and the integration of positive resource states, the name was changed to “Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing” (EMDR). Early controlled clinical trials demonstrated its unique efficacy compared to standard care, spurring rapid adoption and further scientific scrutiny. Today, EMDR is a treatment method recommended by the World Health Organization (WHO) and the American Psychiatric Association (APA).
- The Adaptive Information Processing (AIP) Model
The theoretical foundation of EMDR is the Adaptive Information Processing (AIP) model. AIP posits that the brain possesses an innate physiological system, similar to that which occurs during REM sleep, designed to process and resolve experiences, leading to mental health.
- Dysfunctional Storage: Trauma is understood as an event that overwhelms this innate processing system. Because the event is too intense or the client is too young/vulnerable, the memory fails to link with existing adaptive memory networks. The memory is consequently stored dysfunctionally—isolated and encoded with the original, visceral emotions, negative cognitions (e.g., “I am not safe”), and intense physical sensations present at the time of the event.
- The Traumatic Residue: When the memory is triggered, it is re-experienced in its raw, unprocessed form (a flashback), preventing emotional resolution. This “stuck” memory continues to drive present-day symptoms.
- The EMDR Mechanism: EMDR’s use of BLS is hypothesized to activate the AIP system, linking the isolated traumatic memory with existing, non-traumatic, and adaptive memory networks. This process leads to the integration of the memory, moving it from the highly reactive limbic system (emotional brain) to the neocortex (cognitive brain), where it can be stored as a narrative past event that no longer carries the original emotional charge.
- The Eight-Phase EMDR Protocol
EMDR is defined by its rigorous, sequential, and comprehensive eight-phase protocol. Each phase serves a distinct clinical function, ensuring client readiness, effective memory reprocessing, and durable treatment gains.
- Phases 1 and 2: History Taking and Preparation
The initial phases are critical for establishing the treatment plan and ensuring client stability and safety.
- Phase 1: History Taking and Treatment Planning: The therapist assesses the client’s current distress and history, identifying past traumatic events, current triggers, and future fears. A comprehensive target sequence plan is developed, prioritizing the most distressing or earliest relevant memories for reprocessing. This phase adheres to the principle of “start low and go slow” in terms of clinical complexity.
- Phase 2: Preparation and Stabilization: This crucial phase, which may span several sessions, ensures the client has sufficient ego strength and effective self-soothing/containment resources to manage potential emotional surges during reprocessing. Techniques include teaching clients the “Safe/Calm Place” imagery (a resource installation), the “Container” metaphor for storing overwhelming emotions between sessions, and grounding techniques. BLS is introduced and practiced here to ensure client comfort and familiarity before reprocessing begins.
Connect Free. Improve your mental and physical health with a professional near you
- Phases 3-6: Assessment and Reprocessing
These four phases constitute the core memory reprocessing intervention, following a specific sequence to ensure thorough desensitization and cognitive restructuring.
- Phase 3: Assessment: The therapist identifies the specific memory to be targeted for the session. This includes identifying: the Vivid Image (the worst part of the memory); the Negative Cognition (NC) (e.g., “I am powerless”); the desired Positive Cognition (PC) (e.g., “I have choices now”); the emotional intensity using the Subjective Units of Disturbance (SUD) score (0-10); and the believability of the PC using the Validity of Cognition (VOC) score (1-7).
- Phase 4: Desensitization: The client focuses on the memory while engaging in BLS. The goal is to reduce the SUD score to 0 or 1. The therapist uses short sets of BLS, encouraging the client to simply “let whatever happens, happen,” monitoring the client’s internal associations, images, and shifts in emotional and cognitive content without guiding or directing the process.
- Phase 5: Installation: Once the emotional charge is reduced (SUD low), the client focuses on linking the memory with the desired PC (e.g., “I have choices now”) until the Validity of Cognition (VOC) reaches 6 or 7. This step ensures the memory is integrated with an adaptive belief system.
- Phase 6: Body Scan: The client is instructed to scan their body for any residual physical tension or somatic distress while holding the PC. Any remaining distress is reprocessed with BLS until the body is clear, ensuring the memory is fully resolved on a physiological level.
- Phases 7 and 8: Closure and Re-evaluation
The final phases ensure client safety and assess the durability of the treatment effect.
- Phase 7: Closure: At the end of every session, the therapist ensures the client is grounded and emotionally stable. If reprocessing is incomplete, the client uses the “Container” technique to safely store the residual material until the next session. Homework is assigned to track symptoms and maintain stability.
- Phase 8: Re-evaluation: At the start of the next session, the therapist re-evaluates the previously processed targets by checking the SUD and VOC scores. If the memory remains low in disturbance, the process is deemed complete and a new target is selected. This phase ensures treatment gains are stable and durable.
III. Bilateral Stimulation (BLS) and Mechanisms of Action
The defining feature of EMDR is the use of Bilateral Stimulation, which is integral to the AIP model’s efficacy and therapeutic action.
- Forms of Bilateral Stimulation
While horizontal eye movements are the original and most commonly studied form, BLS can be administered using other sensory channels to suit client preference or clinical necessity:
- Auditory: Alternating sounds delivered via headphones (e.g., clicks or beeps).
- Tactile (Tappers): Alternating vibrations or gentle taps delivered to the client’s hands or knees via handheld devices.
The speed and duration of BLS sets (or “passes”) are carefully tailored to the client’s response, typically ranging from 12 to 24 movements per set.
- The Dual-Attention Stimulus (DAS)
A crucial mechanism theorized to explain BLS’s effect is the Dual-Attention Stimulus (DAS). During reprocessing, the client simultaneously focuses on the distressing internal memory (internal focus) and the external, rhythmic BLS (external focus).
This dual cognitive load is hypothesized to:
- Overload Working Memory (WM): The external BLS competes for resources in the working memory system, weakening the vividness and emotional charge of the traumatic memory being held simultaneously. This creates the space for change.
- Facilitate State Change: The rhythmic, bilateral nature of the BLS is hypothesized to facilitate a shift in brain state (similar to the information processing that occurs during REM sleep), allowing the memory elements to become unstuck and link with adaptive information, leading to eventual resolution.
Free consultations. Connect free with local health professionals near you.
Conclusion
EMDR—The Paradigm Shift in Trauma Resolution
The detailed examination of Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) for trauma confirms its unique position as a highly efficient and integrative psychotherapy. Grounded in the Adaptive Information Processing (AIP) model, EMDR offers a structured, eight-phase protocol that systematically addresses the core mechanism of PTSD: the dysfunctional storage of traumatic memory. By utilizing Bilateral Stimulation (BLS) to activate the brain’s innate healing capacities, EMDR moves beyond the need for detailed narrative exposure, transforming a vivid, emotionally charged residue into an integrated, narrative past event. This conclusion synthesizes the neurobiological efficacy of the BLS, emphasizes the essential role of the preparatory phases in ensuring safety, and outlines EMDR’s significant contribution to the future of rapid, evidence-based trauma care.
- Synthesizing the Mechanism: From Stuck Memory to Resolution
The success of EMDR lies in the systematic application of the protocol to facilitate neurological and emotional shifts that characterize adaptive memory processing.
- The Neurobiological Rationale of BLS
While the exact neurobiological process is still under investigation, the leading hypotheses converge on the idea that BLS temporarily disrupts the rigidity of the traumatic memory, making it pliable for change.
- Decoupling Emotion and Cognition: Research suggests that BLS, particularly eye movements, reduces the accessibility and vividness of the memory, indicating that the emotional circuits in the amygdala (alarm center) and the vivid sensory details are being decoupled from the memory trace. This allows the cognitive parts of the brain (the neocortex) to engage with the memory.
- Hippocampal Integration: The processed memory is theorized to be fully integrated into the hippocampus, the brain region responsible for context and narrative memory. The integrated memory is correctly timestamped and contextualized (“That happened then, not now”), eliminating the physiological re-experiencing (flashbacks) that defines PTSD.
- The REM Sleep Connection: The rhythmic nature of the BLS is hypothesized to mimic the information processing function of Rapid Eye Movement (REM) sleep, a state known to be crucial for consolidating memory and modulating emotional intensity. EMDR essentially jump-starts this natural healing process while the client is conscious and fully resourced.
- The Power of the Positive Cognition (PC)
The goal of EMDR is not just to reduce distress (desensitization), but to install an adaptive belief (reprocessing). The installation of the Positive Cognition (PC) in Phase 5 is the mechanism that ensures the memory is resolved and integrated with a new, healthy self-schema.
- Cognitive Restructuring: The client’s original Negative Cognition (NC) (e.g., “I am worthless”) reflects the psychological injury caused by the trauma. By achieving a high Validity of Cognition (VOC) score for the PC (e.g., “I am safe now”), the client replaces the debilitating, trauma-driven belief with an adaptive one.
- Durability of Change: The linking of the desensitized memory with the PC is what makes the emotional resolution durable. The memory is not simply neutralized; it is recontextualized within a framework of self-efficacy and current safety.
- Clinical Rigor and Safety Considerations
The structured eight-phase protocol ensures EMDR is safe and effective, placing significant emphasis on client readiness and containment.
- The Critical Role of Preparation (Phase 2)
The success of reprocessing hinges almost entirely on the robust execution of Phase 2 (Preparation and Stabilization). Treating trauma without first ensuring the client’s ability to regulate emotion risks re-traumatization.
- Resource Installation: Techniques like the “Safe/Calm Place” and the “Container” are not just relaxation tools; they are installed resources that are linked with BLS. This means the client practices shifting their state using BLS, creating a reliable, internal mechanism for self-soothing that can be instantly deployed if emotional dysregulation occurs during reprocessing.
- Containment for Complex Trauma: For clients with Complex PTSD (CPTSD) resulting from chronic, relational trauma, the preparatory phases are extended, focusing on establishing solid emotional regulation skills, boundary setting, and a secure therapeutic alliance before any direct trauma targets are selected.
- Avoiding Re-traumatization
The adherence to the protocol prevents the “flooding” or uncontrolled emotional release common in non-structured exposure therapies.
- Tapered Desensitization: EMDR uses short, controlled sets of BLS, allowing the client to maintain one foot in the present moment (external BLS) while briefly touching the past memory (internal focus). The therapist constantly monitors the client’s SUD score and degree of dysregulation, ensuring the process remains within the client’s window of tolerance.
- Target Sequencing: The careful sequencing of targets, starting with the least disturbing and progressing to the most disturbing, allows the client to build mastery and confidence, reinforcing the AIP system’s functionality gradually.
- Conclusion: EMDR’s Place in Integrated Care
EMDR represents a paradigm shift because it is a body-centered, neurologically focused therapy that achieves cognitive and emotional insight not through verbal analysis, but through accelerated information processing.
Its contribution lies in:
- Efficiency: Its capacity to resolve single-incident trauma in a limited number of sessions, making it highly resource-effective.
- Integrative Potential: It can be seamlessly integrated with other models (e.g., combining ACT’s values work with EMDR reprocessing) to offer comprehensive treatment.
- Holistic Resolution: The mandatory Body Scan (Phase 6) ensures that resolution is achieved not just intellectually, but somatically—clearing the trauma from the client’s nervous system.
By offering a powerful and proven means to transform the paralyzing residue of trauma into adaptive learning, EMDR allows clients to escape the repetition compulsion of the past and commit their energy to a safe, resourceful present.
Time to feel better. Find a mental, physical health expert that works for you.
Common FAQs
What is the primary purpose of EMDR therapy?
The primary purpose of EMDR is to facilitate the resolution of traumatic memories and other adverse life experiences by stimulating the brain’s natural Adaptive Information Processing (AIP) system.
What is the Adaptive Information Processing (AIP) Model?
The AIP model is the theoretical foundation of EMDR. It posits that trauma overwhelms the brain, causing memories to be dysfunctionally stored (isolated with the original raw emotion). EMDR aims to activate the AIP system to integrate these “stuck” memories into a coherent, adaptive narrative.
Does EMDR require the client to describe the traumatic event in detail?
No. EMDR requires the client to focus on a Vivid Image and associated Negative Cognition (NC), but they do not need to verbally elaborate on the details of the trauma throughout the reprocessing phase. The primary mechanism is internal, not narrative.
Common FAQs
What is Bilateral Stimulation (BLS)?
BLS is the rhythmic, alternating sensory input used during EMDR. It typically involves horizontal eye movements, but can also be delivered via alternating auditory tones or tactile tappers held in the hands.
Why is BLS used? What is the Dual-Attention Stimulus (DAS)?
BLS is hypothesized to activate the AIP system. The Dual-Attention Stimulus (DAS) refers to the client simultaneously focusing on the distressing internal memory and the external, rhythmic BLS. This dual load is believed to overload the working memory temporarily, reducing the vividness and emotional charge of the traumatic memory, thereby making it available for processing.
Is the BLS similar to what happens during REM sleep?
Yes. The rhythmic, bilateral nature of the stimulation is hypothesized to mimic the information processing function that occurs naturally during Rapid Eye Movement (REM) sleep, a state crucial for emotional modulation and memory consolidation.
Common FAQs
What is Bilateral What are the two most critical phases for client safety?(BLS)?
Phase 2 (Preparation and Stabilization) and Phase 7 (Closure). Phase 2 ensures the client has stable resources (like the “Safe/Calm Place” or the “Container”) to manage distress. Phase 7 ensures the client is grounded and stable before leaving the session.
What is the purpose of the SUD and VOC scales?
The Subjective Units of Disturbance (SUD) scale (0-10) measures the emotional distress linked to the memory. The Validity of Cognition (VOC) scale (1-7) measures the client’s belief in the adaptive Positive Cognition (PC). These scales provide objective measurement of the treatment progress and completion.
Why is the Body Scan (Phase 6) included?
The Body Scan ensures that the memory is fully resolved on a somatic (physiological) level, not just emotionally or cognitively. Any residual physical tension or distress is reprocessed until the body is clear, confirming holistic resolution.
Can EMDR cause re-traumatization?
When conducted correctly by a fully trained therapist adhering strictly to the eight-phase protocol, the risk of re-traumatization is low. The careful preparation (Phase 2), the short sets of BLS, and the use of containment resources are designed to keep the client within their window of tolerance throughout the process.
People also ask
Q: What kind of trauma does EMDR help with?
Q:Who shouldn't do EMDR therapy?
Q: What is the best therapy for complex trauma?
Q:Is EMDR or CBT better for trauma?
NOTICE TO USERS
MindBodyToday is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice, diagnosis, medical treatment, or therapy. Always seek the advice of your physician or qualified mental health provider with any questions you may have regarding any mental health symptom or medical condition. Never disregard professional psychological or medical advice nor delay in seeking professional advice or treatment because of something you have read on MindBodyToday.
Share this article
Let us know about your needs
Quickly reach the right healthcare Pro
Message health care pros and get the help you need.
Popular Healthcare Professionals Near You
You might also like
What is Family Systems Therapy: A…
, What is Family Systems Therapy? Everything you need to know Find a Pro Family Systems Therapy: Understanding the Individual […]
What is Synthesis of Acceptance and…
, What is Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT)? Everything you need to know Find a Pro Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT): Synthesizing […]
What is Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT)…
, What is Cognitive Behavioral Therapy ? Everything you need to know Find a Pro Cognitive Behavioral Therapy: Theoretical Foundations, […]
